Almonty's Sangdong Ramp-Up Meets a 69% Tungsten Price Slide and Two Lower Targets

A mill running at full capacity does not, by itself, answer the question of where the output will be sold. That tension sits at the heart of the Almonty story right now: Sangdong keeps reporting operational headway while the tungsten market sends distinctly weaker price signals. Friday's 5.1% share-price decline fits that push-and-pull, though it comes with no confirmed single trigger.

Anyone weighing the stock has to hold two threads apart — progress on the production ramp-up and the conditions under which the mined tungsten will actually be sold. Both belong to the investment case. They are not the same thing.

A different benchmark for the market

Chinese ammonium paratungstate (APT) changed hands at 470,000 yuan per tonne on October 15, according to media reports from October 20. That was roughly 69% below the mid-March peak. The slide paints a materially altered industry backdrop against which Almonty's operating advances are unfolding.

Those reports pointed to weak demand from hard-metal manufacturers, production cuts at smelters and cautious buyers as the drags. This is more than a passing price quote: it describes an environment in which additional production does not automatically meet a receptive market.

Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying Almonty?

No specific selling price or earnings impact for Almonty can be derived from it. The Chinese APT price is not a stated revenue figure for the company. As an industry signal, though, it deserves attention. Narrowing the discussion to Sangdong's technical performance alone would leave the demand side out of the picture.

A new supply source and a soft commodity market can be real at the same time. For investors, that coexistence matters more than hunting for a single positive or negative headline.

What the plant progress actually says

A Diamond Equity Research report published on October 21 described Sangdong's grinding circuit as fully utilized. In early October the mill ran about 16 hours a day. Almonty commissioned and paid for the study, a detail that belongs in any assessment of its conclusions.

Full grinding-circuit utilization is operational progress. It is not the same as a fully worked-off delivery schedule, nor a statement about the economics of the sales. Separating these layers does not require playing down the progress in order to take the remaining questions seriously.

CEO Lewis Black said in his newsletter that the first commercial tungsten shipment from Sangdong was due to leave the mine a little over a week ago. That was the company's account, not an independently confirmed completion notice. The research report expected the second expansion phase to be finished in 2027.

So a concrete ramp-up report sits alongside a further expansion horizon. In my view the real investor question is not whether a single announcement sounds optimistic. What counts is how reliably plant progress translates into a dependable delivery operation.

Timing stays a valuation factor

That this distinction matters for valuation too was shown by Stifel on October 20, when the brokerage cut its price target to US$21 from US$25 while keeping its Buy rating.

Behind the reduction were later delivery assumptions for both Sangdong expansion phases following the investor day. The delivery schedule updated roughly two weeks ago thus remained more than an operational detail — it fed straight into the valuation.

The interesting tension lies in holding the positive rating while lowering the target. Progress can be acknowledged even as its expected economic contribution slips further into the future.

Almonty's story is therefore neither told by a single utilization announcement nor refuted by a weak tungsten price. My yardstick would be the interplay: credible delivery progress at the company level and the market's capacity to absorb it. Only together do they give a more meaningful picture than any single milestone on its own.

Two benchmarks, and a second trimmed target

Almonty ties its corporate narrative closely to the tungsten market. At the October 19 investor day, management laid out both the market environment and the operational development of the portfolio. For investors these levels belong together, yet they are not interchangeable: a read on the commodity market does not answer when individual projects will actually deliver.

Almonty at a turning point? This analysis reveals what investors need to know now.

That distinction makes Sangdong the touchstone. The company newsletter reported the first commercial tungsten shipment and a grinding circuit at full throughput. Almonty also reported begun underground work for the second expansion phase and the ordering of mills.

These are concrete advances. I would not read them as a substitute for a dependable delivery track record. A first shipment proves a milestone has been reached; it does not automatically settle every question about the further ramp-up. Likewise, full throughput in the grinding circuit describes that plant component first and foremost, not the status of all expansion work across the board.

The first commercial shipment, already covered a little over a week ago, remains important context. It is no good as a fresh explanation for every subsequent price move.

Analyst reactions show why the separation matters. On Tuesday, Nick Giles of B. Riley Securities also cut his price target, to US$20 from US$25, while keeping his Buy rating. Both houses thus drew a line between their fundamental recommendation and the level of their target.

For me the more useful framing lies there than in the search for a single explanation of the last trading day. Almonty's operational announcements and the more cautious valuation approaches do not necessarily contradict each other. They illuminate different parts of the same development.

The decisive measure, then, is not whether every advance immediately justifies a higher share price. What matters is whether individual milestones grow into a traceable operating record. Almonty's listed story must be judged on that translation of progress into predictability.

Ad

Almonty Stock: New Analysis - 1 November

Fresh Almonty information released. What's the impact for investors? Our latest independent report examines recent figures and market trends.

Read our updated Almonty analysis...