Almonty's Sangdong Ramp-Up Meets Two Buy Ratings Pulling in Different Directions
Published on 11/16/2026 at 10:01 | Editorial boerse-global.deTwo bullish analyst notes landed on Almonty on the same Friday, yet they told noticeably different stories about how much the tungsten miner is really worth. Stifel cut its price target to US$18 from US$21 while keeping its buy rating, according to media reports. Alliance Global, by contrast, reaffirmed its buy call and a US$26.25 target, framing the recent weakness in the share price as a buying opportunity.
That gap between two identical "buy" labels is where the real investor question sits: how durable is the confidence when higher tungsten prices are driving the business, but the reported profit leans heavily on valuation effects?
A quarter powered by prices, not just output
The economic backdrop comes from the third quarter of 2026. Almonty attributed its sharp revenue jump to higher tungsten prices, tying the company's story to the broader commodity theme. Revenue climbed 382% year-on-year to C$41.89 million, against a Stifel estimate of C$44.9 million. Adjusted operating profit before interest, taxes and depreciation came in at C$14.6 million.
The bottom line needs a closer look. Almonty reported a net profit of C$50.2 million, but that figure included non-cash revaluation gains of C$47.9 million. A large surplus is not automatically proof of the same amount of operating earning power — a distinction that matters more than the shared "buy" tag on the two analyst notes.
Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying Almonty?
Stifel's cut pointed to costs and the revenue miss. Alliance Global acknowledged that results came in modestly below expectations during the Sangdong ramp-up, while still calling the pullback an opportunity. Both houses concede there were disappointments against forecasts; they simply weigh them differently.
From first concentrate to first container
The operational thread runs from production to delivery. Almonty said on Thursday that Sangdong produced tungsten concentrate for the first time in September. After the quarter closed, the first shipping container was loaded in Busan. Those are separate milestones — output first, then transport — and they do not yet prove consistently reliable execution.
On the sales side, more than 90% of Phase I production from Sangdong was contractually committed, according to the company. That binding is a useful signal for offtake, though it is not the same as booked revenue or realized profit. Contract coverage and earnings quality answer different questions.
Almonty at a turning point? This analysis reveals what investors need to know now.
A courtroom test runs alongside
Separately, the dispute with Deutsche Rohstoff remains live. The company said on Wednesday it is asserting claims of roughly USD 67 million against Almonty in Canada, including 3.5 million conversion shares and repayment of debt. Deutsche Rohstoff also said Almonty has filed its own suit and that the proceedings have been consolidated. The claims should therefore be treated as the subject of litigation, not as a fixed payment obligation.
Weighing it all up, Almonty cannot be reduced to either the growth spurt or the trimmed expectations. Production and shipping mark genuine operational progress. The analyst reactions and the legal fight add economic and legal stress tests on top. The share price moved -2.0% in one reading and gained 8.5% on the Friday in question — a reminder of how sharply sentiment is swinging around this name. What matters next is whether the ramp-up now under way converts into dependable business results.
Ad
Almonty Stock: New Analysis - 16 November
Fresh Almonty information released. What's the impact for investors? Our latest independent report examines recent figures and market trends.
