Alphabet's AI Spending Under the Microscope as Two Analysts Trim Targets and a Third Raises His

Alphabet shares fell 3.0% in yesterday's session, caught in a broad selloff across the technology sector rather than driven by any fresh operating disclosure from the company itself. Reuters reported that investor doubts over the costs and returns of AI investments resurfaced, with Meta's AI-related cash outflows and financing plans adding fuel to those concerns. The move leaves shareholders weighing a familiar question in sharper form: can the company's expanding artificial-intelligence lineup translate into earnings power strong enough to offset mounting pressure on its core search business?

Two analysts cut their price targets this week while keeping their positive ratings intact, a combination that says more about valuation discipline than about any loss of conviction. Andrew Boone of Citizens JMP lowered his target to $450 from $515 yesterday while maintaining a "Market Outperform" rating, citing competition from AI agents in search and execution risks. On Monday, Justin Patterson at KeyBanc trimmed his target to $410 from $435 and stayed "Overweight," pointing to lower earnings estimates for Google Services and a more conservative assessment of TPU contributions to Google Cloud. BMO moved the other way, lifting its target to $480.

The revised Citizens number rests on roughly 28 times its 2027 GAAP earnings estimate of $16.24 per share, down from a richer multiple applied previously. Boone's team also flagged tougher comparables for advertising growth and uncertainty around YouTube advertising, meaning the debate is not solely about how fast Alphabet rolls out AI products but about how well the existing franchise holds up in the meantime. The firm still considers Alphabet well positioned across search, artificial intelligence, online video and Waymo.

Cloud momentum collides with capacity limits

On the other side of the ledger sits Google Cloud, where demand is running well ahead of Alphabet's ability to serve it. Revenue in the quarter through June jumped 82%, and the backlog reached $514 billion. Yet a hefty order book does not convert into near-term revenue on its own. CEO Sundar Pichai said in a podcast published Tuesday that Google Cloud is temporarily turning away business, reserving scarce computing capacity primarily for DeepMind and finding it difficult to free up additional capacity for cloud customers.

Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying Alphabet?

The spending picture is equally demanding. Alphabet plans capital expenditures of $195–205 billion for 2026, and management expects investment to rise significantly the following year, with continued pressure on free cash flow. Citizens anticipates higher outlays next year as well. Against that backdrop, favorable pricing and better utilization could unlock extra growth, and over the longer run AI models and agents are expected to support business development — with the analysts judging the risks largely priced in despite investment concerns.

Wednesday's partnership with OpenAI offers a tangible data point for the bullish case. Under the arrangement reported by Reuters, leading OpenAI models including GPT-6 Astra and Codex will be offered through Google Cloud's Model Garden and Marketplace, with general availability planned for the coming weeks. That is an expansion of the offering, not a proven earnings contribution — a favorable scenario would see the added models lift Google Cloud's appeal and generate economic benefit, but the announcement opens that possibility without demonstrating it. New Gemini tools for small businesses unveiled Tuesday fit the same pattern: they broaden the practical applications on offer, though what matters for the investment case is whether such tools eventually deliver a durable contribution to earnings.

Search competition is the other flank

Boone's warning about AI agents cuts directly to the competitive outlook for search, and it extends beyond general nervousness in the tech sector. Should those risks carry more weight, additional cloud offerings alone may not be enough to settle investor concerns. Combined with Patterson's more cautious view of earnings contributions, two distinct reservations now sit side by side: doubt about the future competitive position, and restraint on expected profit contributions. In a bearish scenario Alphabet would need not only to explain the benefits of new offerings but also to dispel fears that earnings prospects are falling short of prior expectations.

Alphabet at a turning point? This analysis reveals what investors need to know now.

The next concrete catalyst is third-quarter 2026 results, scheduled for release after the market close on October 28. Higher revenues and year-over-year profit growth are expected, with attention focused on search advertising growth and the trajectory of the cloud backlog. Revenue growth alone will not settle the matter — clues on how Alphabet converts demand into available capacity and ultimately into free cash flow will carry equal weight. Citizens remains optimistic, though it now applies a lower valuation yardstick to that view.

The choice facing investors is not between AI and no AI. It is between an earnings outlook that becomes more credible and the risk that competition and more cautious valuations overwhelm the expected benefits of new offerings. As long as the economic promise of the expanded AI lineup convinces and search risks appear contained, the positive scenario holds together; should profit expectations slip further, even a stream of product announcements may not be enough to force a convincing re-rating.

Ad

Alphabet Stock: New Analysis - 23 October

Fresh Alphabet information released. What's the impact for investors? Our latest independent report examines recent figures and market trends.

Read our updated Alphabet analysis...